For baseball aficionados like you, I have divided the list into three sections. The lower-end catcher’s mitt 2019 variants come first, followed by the budget option, and then the high-end mitts section completes the list.
Catcher’s mitt 2019 models are distinctively different from all other baseball gloves out there. More often they are called catcher’s mitt, as they do not have any fingers. This increases the longevity of the glove and makes catching less painful. On the other hand, this kind of glove takes a very long time to break in. They are very rigid, have lots of padding and are built to withstand high impacts, as they are used to for catching a lot of fast balls. Just take a look at the batting averages in professional games and you have a clue how many balls a catcher’s mitt has to stop mid-air during a regular game.
This article has affiliate links, which means I receive compensation if you purchase a product through this link. There are no additional costs for you. It helps me continuing this blog. Thanks for your support! Visit my disclosure page for more information.
Entry-level Baseball Catching Mitts
Rawlings Renegade 32.5″ Catcher’s Mitt
Material: Oil-tanned full grain leather
Webbing: One-piece solid webbing
Size: 32.5″
The Rawlings Renegade 32.5″ Catcher’s Mitt 2019 is a great glove for those looking to get into the game of baseball. For the price point at which the Rawlings is being offered, you will rarely find better mitt than this one.
Design
The design is good (not great), and the glove is almost game-ready right out of the gate. The mitt has a deep pocket to help you catch and scoop the balls in the dirt every time. It also comes with a speed wrist strap for easy closing. The leather palm and lightweight Pro Mesh back add to the durability of the glove and make it surprisingly comfortable to wear.
Who it’s for?
This catcher’s mitt 2019 is for anyone looking to play baseball semi-regularly.
Mizuno Franchise 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt: GXC90B2
Material: Pre-oiled Java leather
Webbing: Two-Piece Closed Web
Size: 33.5″
The Mizuno Franchise 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt: GXC90B2 is a great entry-level glove. If you are looking for a glove to give to your nephew or your kid, this might be the one.
Design
The design is simple, and the catcher’s mitt 2019 has a game-ready feel and the breaking-in process is minimal. It has a very natural hand shape that sits comfortably on your hand. The open-back design makes it easier for you to insert your finger and shape the mitt.
The glove is made with Java leather which gives the mitt its durability. The para shock plus palm hand take away the sting that comes with catching the ball.
Who it’s for?
This glove is for entry-level players in the game of baseball.
Rawlings R9 CM 32.5″ Catcher’s Mitt
Material: Durable All Leather
Webbing: One-piece solid web
Size: 32.5″
The Rawlings R9 CM 32.5″ Catcher’s Mitt may not be the best or the most professional catching glove, but it is cheap and a particularly good buy for an entry-level glove.
Design
The design of the glove is good and doesn’t betray the true price of the glove; it gives off the vibe of being a more expensive catcher’s mitt 2019. The color is a mix of brown and chocolate brown and gives the mitt a rugged appearance. The glove is built using solely leather and sits comfortably on the hand and is going to last you a long time. The padded palm softens the impact of the glove, and the thumb has a padded thumb loop, plus the finger back is also lined.
Who it’s for?
This glove is for everyone and anyone who plays baseball.
Wilson A1000 CM33 33″ Catcher’s Mitt
Material: Full grain leather
Webbing: Half Moon web
Size: 33″
The Wilson A1000 CM33 33″ Catcher’s Mitt may not be the best glove in town, but it is a good glove to take to your amateur baseball league.
Design
The design and color scheme of this mitt is simple and basic, and the look is a mixture of ruggedness and simple elegance.
The glove is built with full grain leather. The fingertips are lined, and the palm is padded to make catching the ball easier. The webbing design is simple and basic. The webbing is sure to help you catch and leave the ball nestled in the pocket of the glove.
Who it’s for?
This catcher’s mitt 2019 is a good pick for entry-level baseball players.
The Budget Options
Mizuno Pro Select 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt (the logical option)
Material: US Kip leather
Webbing: Two-piece closed web
Size: 33.5″
The Mizuno Pro Select 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt is a valuable budget buy. The money for which this glove is sold, and the quality of the glove make it a deal at this price point.
Design
The design is very baseball-oriented and gives the mitt a simple look. The glove will last you a good, long while. The hand-based pattern structure allows for safer catching, and the excellent craftsmanship makes picking and catching much more comfortable.
The glove is made with US Kip leather that adds to the firm, rigorous feel. Kip leather is the best kind of leather for baseball gloves, as it is very durable, but also offers a lot of feel at the same time. Normally gloves at this price point do not use kip leather, so this is definitely a pleasant surprise.
The soft elite palm liner with the padded thumb spot make for a more secure fit. The hand-based pattern comes under the web and makes the mitt more secure for catching. The glove is comfortable to wear and will help you catch a lot of balls over the course of several hundred games.
Who it’s for?
This glove is for everyone—from the amateur baseball enthusiast to the professional player.
Wilson A2000 CM33 33″ Catcher’s Mitt (the challenger)
Material: Pro-Stock select leather
Webbing: Half Moon web
Size: 33″
The Wilson A2000 CM33 33″ Catcher’s Mitt could be the long-lost cousin of the Mizuno Pro Select 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt. Both have the same design and similar professional build quality. It is only the look that sets them apart.
Design
The design of the Wilson A2000 is good. The dual welting makes for a very solid glove and helps the glove retain its shape. It also adds to the durability of the glove. The updated flat finger binding helps the glove have a softer and comfortable feel to it.
The glove is crafted with pro-stock American leather. The hide makes the break in process more manageable, while the Dri-Lex moisture-wicking wrist lining will help your hand stay dry. The build quality is excellent, and the glove is amazingly comfortable to wear. This mitt is a good buy for repetitive catches, catching lots and lots of balls.
Who it’s for?
Everyone and anyone who plays baseball will love using this glove. If you want to catch the ball in a game of baseball, the Wilson A2000 CM33 33″ Catcher’s Mitt will serve you for a long time.
Rawlings Heart of the Hide CM33BSL 33″ Catcher’s Mitt (the all-rounder)
Material: HOH Steer-hide leather
Webbing: One-piece solid web
Size: 33″
With the advancement in baseball catching gloves, a lot of great gloves are on the market just waiting for you to pluck them off the shelves. The Rawlings Heart of the Hide CM33BSL 33″ Catcher’s Mitt is one of the greatest budgets catcher’s mitt 2019 models available to the average baseball player today.
Design
The design of the Rawlings Heart of the Hide CM33BSL 33″ Catcher’s Mitt is striking, to say the least. The Rawlings’ heart has a black-brown color scheme, and the overall design of the glove is very sporty. It is sure to make you stand out in the field.
The build quality of these particular mitts is excellent, especially for this price point. The glove uses the top 5 percent of the hide available; deer tanned cowhide palm also lines the glove. The fingers are lined with soft leather so that wearing the mitt is a satisfying experience. It is sure to last a long time. The webbing design of the glove is excellent and is sure to make the catching the ball easier.
Who it’s for?
This glove is simply for those people that play and enjoy the game of baseball. When it comes to baseball, it will be the Alfred to your Batman.
Wilson A2000 Road PUDGE 32.5″ Catcher’s Mitt (a good buy)
Material: Pro-Stock steer-hide leather
Webbing: Half Moon web
Size: 32.5″
The Wilson A2000 Road PUDGE 32.5″ Catcher’s Mitt is an excellent buy for the money. A durable, superbly built glove with a basic design, it is a good catching glove.
Design
The mitt was designed with input from the great Ivan Rodriquez. The design of the glove offers increased mobility and durability. It has a very rugged feel to it and is built with pro-stock leather. The dual welting makes it a great glove to catch balls with and adds to the durability of the glove.
The break in process of the gloves is also sure to be easy. Also, the Dri-Lex wrist lining will keep your hands dry.
Who it’s for?
This glove is perfect for all baseball enthusiasts of all levels and ages.
High-End Gloves
Mizuno Pro 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt (the premium for the professionals)
Material: US Kip leather
Webbing: Two-piece solid web
Size: 33.5″
The Mizuno Pro 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt is as high-end as they come. It personifies quality and has been lovingly crafted by its maker specifically for catchers.
Design
The Mizuno Pro 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt has a modern, sleek, smooth, and sporty design. The design is as functional as it is elegant and will be right at home on any baseball field. The most striking features of the design of this stunning catcher’s mitt 2019 are the hand-based pattern of the glove—it has pockets under the webbing which allows for the glove to be more easily shaped—and the palm pad, which has been expertly crafted to reduce the sting that a catcher’s hand might feel at impact of the ball. The palm pad also does a superb job of deadening the ball at impact.
It is a premium glove for professional players. The build quality of the glove is excellent. It is made using Japanese tanned Kip leather. The shell leather that lines the palm is soft to the touch and feel. The Mizuno should be good for a long, comfortable game.
The back of the glove has an open design, as one might expect, and the webbing has a two-piece solid web pattern to easily catch or scoop the ball in the dirt. Playing baseball with this catcher’s mitt is indeed a wonderful experience.
Who it’s for?
The Mizuno Pro 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt is perfect for any serious player.
Wilson A2K M1 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt (the long-lasting champion)
Material: Pro-Stock steer-hide leather
Webbing: Half Moon web
Size: 33.5″
The Wilson A2K M1 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt is a premium baseball catcher’s mitt. The mitt has been built to last as long as possible. It is no slouch in other departments either; this mitt is sure to give you a nice all-rounder experience.
Design
The Wilson A2K M1 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt is made like the old baseball catching gloves. It has a classic look and feel to it. The design marries the modern sleekness of sport with the classical look of the yesteryear. The design helps it retain its shape and build. It also offers a superior pocket and better web stability.
The glove has it all: it features dual welting, combined with a double palm construction. It is made with durable Pro-Stock select leather. The durable Pro-Stock select leather gives the glove more stability and an unmatched feel among all its catcher’s mitt counterparts. The double palm welting provides the glove with stability. The dual welting adds to the durability of the glove, giving it a more durable pocket and a quicker break in period.
The Half Moon webbing allows you to farm pitches on the black, snag balls in the dirt, and tag out runners trying to score; this quality baseball glove will help you be a better baseball player.
Who it’s for?
This glove is the right fit for any catcher that wants to have a reliable and durable piece of equipment.
All-Star Pro Elite Series Baseball Catcher’s Mitt: CM3000SBT Catcher’s Mitt (a true-ish catcher’s mitt)
Material: Japanese tanned US steer-hide leather
Webbing: Reinforced closed web
Size: 33.5″
With a name like All-Star Pro Elite Series Baseball Catcher’s Mitt (CM3000SBT Catcher’s Mitt), you can’t go wrong. The glove has a superb design, brilliant build quality, and excellent durability. It breaks in fast and should serve you ably in over several hundred games.
Design
The All-Star Pro Elite Series Baseball Catcher’s Mitt (CM3000SBT Catcher’s Mitt) has a very professional design, and it should come as no surprise that this catcher’s mitt is a popular choice among the pros. The black back not only looks elegant and sexy but also provides just the right amount of support for handling and, more importantly, controlling the ball.
The All-Star Pro has a 33.5″ pattern and a reinforced web which is the perfect choice for an elite catcher. The back of the glove does away with bulkiness and instead adds to the smoothness and the comfort level of the glove.
It is built with exclusive Japanese tanned steer-hide leather. The glove uses only the best material and boasts the finest hand craftsmanship. The soft leather has a great feel to it, and the look of the glove is stunning. The soft leather is also exceptionally durable and gives the ball that extra oomph that pitchers like to feel.
The reinforced closed web adds to the durable feel of the glove. The web design makes this glove the perfect choice for all elite players.
Who it’s for?
The All-Star is individually made and handcrafted; this makes the glove a perfect fit for a pros. If it is sufficient for a professional, than it should also be good enough for you.
Rawlings Gold Glove CM43 34″ Catcher’s Mitt (detailed craftsmanship)
Material: Kip leather
Webbing: One-piece solid web
Size: 34″
The Rawlings Gold Glove CM43 34″ Catcher’s Mitt has the trifecta of admirable build quality, excellent design, and durability. It is built using only the best materials. The Gold Glove has a great design. It’s a glove you cannot go wrong with.
Design
The impeccable Kip leather provides the Rawlings Gold Glove CM43 34″ Catcher’s Mitt with a rather unique look and feel. The 100 percent wool padding adds to the durability of the glove and helps it to retain its shape. The thumb-to-pinky close is specifically designed to improve ball security. Once the ball nestles into the glove, it isn’t going anywhere. The padded thumb sleeve adds to the comfort level of the glove, and it is these little things that make this glove stand out from the crowd. The calfskin does an excellent job of wiping away the sweat, too.
The build of this glove is excellent. It is made with Kip leather and laced with Tennessee Tanning rawhide leather to give the mitt its strength and durability. The quality of the leather should make it extremely easy to break in the glove.
The webbing is closed-designed and is supposed to be the best in the business. Every aspect of this glove is meticulously detailed, and the craftsmanship is first-rate.
Who it’s for?
This is made for the elite, and the elite players use it. That shouldn’t stop you from using it in your amateur baseball league. If you want to be the best, you will need to use the best materials at your disposal, and the Rawlings Gold Glove CM43 34″ Catcher’s Mitt is truly the best.
Mizuno Pro Limited Edition 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt: GMP200J (the limited-edition wonder)
Material: Deguchi Northern European Kip leather
Webbing: Two-piece closed web
Size: 33.5″
The Mizuno Pro Limited Edition 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt: GMP200J is a limited-edition baseball glove. It is unique and has impressive build quality, excellent open design, and it is going to last you a long, long time.
Design
The mitt has a 33.5″ pattern design. It comes in a stunning chestnut color which makes it stand out from the crowd.
The Mizuno Pro Limited is built with a Japanese tanned Northern European Kip leather that has a propriety tanning process, tighter fibers, and has been perfectly conditioned to be tough and robust. The rolled welting gives it a fresh and a rather unique look, and the pocket of the glove makes it perfect for catching the ball.
Wanna know what the coolest part about this glove is? You basically buy two gloves instead of one, as Mizuno offers a one time free reconditioning for this glove. This will restore its original condition and give you a new glove. Great stuff.
Who it’s for?
This glove is somewhat challenging to find and if you have the money and the time to find one, then, by all means, go for it. It is a great buy.
Get home safe,
Jan